Atom and GML Simple for OpenLayers

Update (2008-02-21)

Protocol discussion ongoing at: http://trac.openlayers.org/wiki/Proposal/Protocols

This week I finally got around to working on a task that's been haunting me: OpenLayers as an AtomPub client. Chris Schmidt has done much of the work already, but I'm going to see it all the way through over the next few months.

A quick review of AtomPub and how it relates to geospatial applications is probably needed here. There are 3 different types of resources in the Atom Publishing Protocol (omitting for now workspaces): services, collections, and entries. the analogous components in a GIS architecture are: services, featuretypes (or coverages), and features. An AtomPub service document is in some ways like an OWS capabilities document, but simpler because AtomPub doesn't fool around with non-HTTP semantics and bakes more metadata into its single protocol. An Atom feed document is rather a lot like a WFS feature collection document, and an Atom entry is also much like a GML feature, but much more standardized. OpenLayers does WFS already, and needs little modification to be a good AtomPub client.

Here's the little modification that I have done: a new OpenLayers.Format.Atom lets me ignore the jumble of namespaces and elements that is RSS 1 and 2. This Atom.js is simpler than GeoRSS.js. The Atom entry atom:content element is the prime avenue for extending Atom, and I've also added support for that. Best practice for georeferencing Atom entries is to use a GML simple features geometry (see OGC 06-049r1) within a georss:where element and OpenLayers.Format.GMLSF supports simple features GML within my new Atom format. The GMLSF format writes gml:pos and gml:posList only, no gml:coordinates, and uses "exterior" and "interior" as ring element tags. On the other hand, it is just as forgiving as OpenLayers.Format.GML when reading. So now an OpenLayers app can write well calibrated feature entries to be POSTed to an AtomPub-style collection like the one at http://sgillies.net/kw/++rest++knowhere/demo. (I'll explain the odd URL in a future post).

That collection is live. I've copied over a few entries from my Hammock app like so:

sean@lenny:~$ curl -X GET http://sgillies.net/hammock/places/6.atom > 6.atom
sean@lenny:~$ curl -X POST -v \
-H "Content-Type: application/atom+xml" \
-H "Slug: Navarro Vineyards" \
--data @6.atom \
http://sgillies.net/kw/++rest++knowhere/demo
* About to connect() to sgillies.net port 80
*   Trying ...... connected
* Connected to sgillies.net (...) port 80
> POST /kw/++rest++knowhere/demo HTTP/1.1
> User-Agent: curl/7.15.5 (i486-pc-linux-gnu) ...
> Host: sgillies.net
> Accept: */*
> Content-Type: application/atom+xml
> Slug: Wehlener Sonnenuhr
> Content-Length: 1301
> Expect: 100-continue
>
< HTTP/1.1 100 Continue
HTTP/1.1 201 Created
< Date: Sun, 17 Feb 2008 20:46:21 GMT
< Server: Twisted/2.5.0 ...
< Content-Length: 73
< Accept-Ranges: bytes
< X-Content-Type-Warning: guessed from content
< Location: http://sgillies.net/kw/++rest++knowhere/demo/wehlener-sonnenuhr
< Content-Type: text/plain;charset=utf-8
Connection #0 to host sgillies.net left intact
* Closing connection #0
Location: http://sgillies.net/kw/++rest++knowhere/demo/wehlener-sonnenuhr

(The ability to copy resources is built into HTTP.) If you browse to http://sgillies.net/kw/demo/map (and wait a few seconds for a pile of javascript to download) you'll see this placemark displayed among others as a vector layer in an OpenLayers map of the demo collection. Toward implementing AtomPub, I have a second vector to serve as a buffer for to-be-posted placemarks. Draw a new geometry in the map using the OpenLayers tools and you'll see it in green. Then set a title, summary, text, a placemark name slug, and click "post". If you've picked a slug that collides with an existing placemark name, you'll see an error message. Otherwise, you'll see the location of the newly created placemark.

Still yet to do are placemark edit and deletion as Chris's AtomPub demo already does. I think that getting this right will require a new OpenLayers.Layer.AtomPub, one that behaves much like the existing WFS layer, but interacts with the server using GET/PUT/DELETE/POST. The protocol implementation, such as it is, currently exists in this page template. The only real novelty in it is the use of the HTTP Slug request header to make suggestions for resource names.

function postPlacemark() {
  var feature = buffer.features[0];
  feature.attributes.title = $("pm-title").value;
  feature.attributes.description = $("pm-summary").value;
  feature.attributes["content"] = $("pm-content").value;
  var atom = format.write(feature);
  var options = {
    method: "post",
    contentType: "application/atom+xml",
    postBody: atom,
    onSuccess: updatePage,
    onFailure: function(xhr) {
      update_status("Failed post (status code "+xhr.status+"). Check your URL.");
    },
  };
  var slug = $("pm-slug").value;
  if (slug.length > 0) {
    options.requestHeaders = ["Slug", slug];
  }
  new OpenLayers.Ajax.Request(collection_URL, options);
}

My server has the final say, and currently just lowercases the slugs and replaces whitespace with a dash.

I submitted the new Atom and GMLSF formats to OpenLayers (#1366) and look forward to working with the developers to get them into an upcoming release.

Comments

Re: Atom and GML Simple for OpenLayers

Author: Yves Moisan

Nice! Eventually being able to delete a vertex while editing (or after) would be useful. I'm a dyslexic typer :-)

Re: Atom and GML Simple for OpenLayers

Author: Tim Schaub

Sounds good Sean. The scattered protocol logic in OpenLayers has been bugging me for a while. I've been tossing around ideas for a protocol class (related to vector CRUD protocols). Before you go following the WFS mess (in OpenLayers) and create an AtomPub layer, please get in touch. I'd like to work on something together that would benefit us all.

Re: Atom and GML Simple for OpenLayers

Author: Brian Flood

hi sean can you keep me in the loop as well? I'd be happy to do whatever I can with the OpenLayers support but I'm also interested in a .net client to AtomPub (for use in a non web editor like ArcMap). It would be nice to syncronize with what you all have done so far. also, of interest is MS's recent decision to make AtomPub the publishing basis for their future ADO.NET Data Services [1]. Their Url schema, while open, is slightly different then what has been discussed for geo-enabled atompub feed (filtering, querying etc). any thoughts? cheers brian [1] AtomPub in Astoria Lots more info in this document: Astoria link

Re: Atom and GML Simple for OpenLayers

Author: Sean

Brian, we're going to take the discussion here: http://trac.openlayers.org/wiki/Proposal/Protocols (initial version by Chris Schmidt). I don't follow Astoria at all, but its convergence with AtomPub seems to be big and good news.